BUSINESS SUPERFANS® ADVANTAGE • EPISODE 14
Customer Experience
Revenue Reactor Discipline
Customer Experience
Blocked Growth Addressed
The primary growth blocker is transactional thinking: treating customers, employees, and grocery store partners as sales instead of relationships, so loyalty and repeat orders fade as soon as nobody is paying attention.
Primary Stakeholder
Customers
Additional Stakeholders
Employees, Retail Partners (grocery stores), Distributors, Family Members in the Business, Local Media, Farmers Market Shoppers
Primary Topic
Building Loyal Customers, Employees, and Retail Partners in a Growing Food Business
DIRECT ANSWER
Customers, employees, and retail partners stay loyal when they feel noticed. Jannie Teitelbaum greets every shopper, keeps her loyalty reward within quick reach, rewards her team and works around their lives, and visits and calls the grocery stores that carry her pies. Small, regular attention brings people back and keeps stores reordering.
Why This Guest’s Perspective Matters
Jannie Teitelbaum founded Great Lakes Pot Pies in Clawson, Michigan, and grew it from her home kitchen to a commercial kitchen, two farmers markets, a retail store opened in April 2020, and a distribution deal covering all of Michigan and much of Ohio. She is the contact for the 42 grocery stores that carry her pies, has appeared on local Fox television eight to ten times, and says she has lost only two employees, one to retirement and one to a move.
Key Discoveries From This Conversation
- Root cause: loyalty started face to face. Before social media, Jannie built her first following at the farmers market. "It was really just a face to face time that really built those relationships," she says, and those regulars told their friends.
- Misconception: a loyalty program needs a big prize. Her Square point system gives 100 points for every $10 and $5 off at 1,000 points. "So we've made it so that the customer can get there very quickly," she says.
- Strategic shift: grocery stores are relationships, not accounts. Store managers told Jannie that small brands they stock "never hear from them again" except to push orders, so she sends people in just to say hello.
- Practical method: the demo cycle. The store orders ahead of an in-store sampling, sells a batch during it, then has to reorder. Jannie aims for a demo about every month and a half at nearby stores and posts a photo of the demo the same day.
- Business consequence: the team is the business. "If they're not motivated to do that, I'm going to be out of business because I can't do it myself," Jannie says. She has lost only one employee to retirement and one to a move.
- Measurable outcome: steady new traffic. Organic Facebook growth to about 8,000 followers, plus targeted Facebook ads, means half of the store's customers are new, by Jannie's count.
- Make every visitor feel known. Greet each person who walks in and keep the space bright and inviting, like the neighborhood store where everyone knew your name.
- Put the first reward within reach. A program customers can finish in a visit or two brings them back; one they'll never complete feels like a gimmick.
- Give regulars a reason to return. A rotating lineup, like a new taco pie, gives weekly customers something new to try.
- Let signs and names start the conversation. Street signs for "Thanksgiving in a Pie" and taco pie bring curious people through the door.
- Celebrate your team and say yes to their lives. Lunches after a hard week, big birthdays, and flexible schedules keep people smiling at work.
- Correct in private, and mind the delivery. How you say something matters as much as what you say.
- Grow at a pace you can serve. Jannie picked a regional distributor over a multi-state one so growth wouldn't outrun production.
1:42 — From semi-retired to pot pies — How one pie at a women's network meeting became a business.4:04 — Commercial kitchen and farmers markets — The weekly face time that built the first loyal customers.6:21 — The turkey dance — The in-store moment customers spent over $100 to see.8:06 — A loyalty program customers can reach — Newsletter specials and Square points that pay out fast.9:52 — Greeting every customer — The neighborhood-store feel that brings people back every week.12:41 — Turning employees into Superfans — Lunches, birthdays, and saying yes to time off.15:38 — Opening a store in a pandemic — An April 2020 launch and a hole in the wall to grow.17:02 — Growing without micromanaging — Choosing a distributor, 42 stores, and correcting in private.21:59 — Keeping grocery stores as fans — Store visits, in-store demos, and shelf signs.24:13 — Organic followers and Facebook ads — Why half the customers are new every day.
PUT THIS INTO PRACTICE
Call three of the businesses that carry or refer your work this week. Don't ask for anything. Ask how things are going, what's working, and what's not, and offer one small thing that would help them, such as a sign, a sample, or a quick visit. Put the next call on your calendar before you hang up.
I met Jannie at a Panera in Michigan when she was still making pies in her kitchen. What she built since then has very little to do with a secret recipe. It comes down to relationships.
Look at how she treats each group. Customers get greeted at the door and a reward they can earn in a visit or two. Employees get lunch after a hard week, a big deal made of their birthday, and a yes when they need a doctor's appointment. Grocery stores get a visit or a call just to ask how things are going, not only when she wants an order.
That last one is where most small brands drop the ball. Store managers told her they buy from small businesses and never hear from them again. Jannie shows up, runs a demo, posts a photo of it, and the store reorders.
And her team stays. One person retired, one moved up north, and that's it. People will crawl through broken glass for appreciation and recognition. Give your customers, your team, and your partners a reason to feel noticed, and they'll carry your business for you.
How did Jannie Teitelbaum start Great Lakes Pot Pies?
Jannie Teitelbaum was semi-retired and making healthy bars when people told her they needed dinner. She worked on a chicken pot pie recipe for almost a year, brought one to a women's business network meeting, and a member bought one on the spot. She moved into a church's commercial kitchen and built her following at local farmers markets before opening her store.
How does the Great Lakes Pot Pies loyalty program work?
Jannie Teitelbaum says customers earn 100 points for every $10 they spend through Square, using just their phone number, and get $5 off when they reach 1,000 points. She set it up so customers reach a reward quickly. The mailing list adds a discount or special in almost every newsletter her son Steven sends.
How does Jannie Teitelbaum keep grocery stores ordering her pies?
Jannie Teitelbaum sends people, including herself, to visit the stores that carry her pies and calls the ones too far away to ask what's selling. Her team runs in-store demos about every month and a half at nearby stores. Stores order before a demo, sell a batch during it, and then reorder.
How has Jannie Teitelbaum kept her employees for so long?
Jannie Teitelbaum says she has lost only two employees, one who retired and one who moved. She buys lunch after hard weeks, makes a big deal of birthdays, never says no to doctor's appointments or needed time off, and gives any correction politely and in private. She says her business depends on a motivated team.
- Great Lakes Pot Pies — Jannie Teitelbaum's handmade pot pie company in Clawson, Michigan, with a retail store, grocery distribution, and nationwide shipping.
- Square — The point-of-sale system that runs the store's phone-number loyalty program and keeps track of points.
- Facebook — Where Great Lakes Pot Pies built its organic following and runs targeted ads.
- Instagram — The company's other main social channel, listed under Great Lakes Pot Pies.
No current sponsor or approved-partner tools were discussed. Jannie mentioned Square for her loyalty program and Facebook for organic growth and ads, along with her own Great Lakes Pot Pies website and mailing list.
Keep Exploring
EPISODE 13
Steve Feld
Customer Experience
Most service businesses go quiet after the sale, then wonder why referrals and repeat customers dry up. Business coach Steve Feld explains how thank-you cards, employee recognition, easy-to-earn rewards, and fair referral agreements turn customers, staff, and partners into Superfans without more marketing spend.
Explore Episode 13 →
EPISODE 213

Frederick Dudek
Culture
Frederick Dudek (Freddy D) uses a true story about a customer who spent $112 on chicken pot pies on purpose to reveal the most underused marketing asset in most businesses: the frontline employee, and why recognition — not customer-facing tactics — has to come first.
Explore Episode 213 →
EPISODE 12
Catherine Oaks
Marketing
Most small businesses talk about themselves and quit marketing too soon. Catherine Oaks, founder of SliiceXR, explains how customer-centric messaging, one consistent brand across every channel, and at least nine touchpoints build brand awareness and turn customers into Superfans.
Explore Episode 12 →
Great Lakes Pot Pies
Guest Offer
Jannie Teitelbaum invites listeners to join the Great Lakes Pot Pies mailing list for 10% off right away. The company ships across the country in one or two days, depending on where you are, with shipping bundles on the website so you can try a variety of pies. Visit greatlakespotpies.com, or visit the store in Clawson, Michigan.
Topic Tags
Customer Retention, Loyalty Programs, Customer Experience, Employee Recognition, Team Culture, Retail Partnerships, Social Media Marketing, Stakeholder Ecosystem