Most hiring mistakes look fine on paper. The candidate has the right title, the right years of experience, and every keyword in the job description. Six months later they're gone, the role is open again, and the team that covered the gap is a little more tired and a little less sure of leadership.
The problem usually isn't the candidate pool. It's what companies measure. A résumé tells you what someone has done. It says very little about how they perform when conditions change, whether their temperament fits the role, or whether your company will give them a reason to stay.
This article draws on Frederick Dudek's conversation with Michael McDonald on Business Superfans® Advantage, Episode 16: Effective Company Culture and Employee Satisfaction: Mike McDonald's Approach.
The Problem: Hiring the Résumé Instead of the Person
Michael McDonald is the founder and president of M. W. McDonald & Associates, the executive search firm known as MWM Search, which has built teams for high-technology companies since 1991. After 28 years in recruiting, he describes good hiring in three words: skills, personality, culture.
Most companies spend nearly all their attention on the first word. They screen for technical ability, hire the closest match, and treat everything else as luck. That approach misses two of the three things that decide whether a hire works out.
- Skills answer whether the person can do the work.
- Personality answers how they're wired: how assertive, how patient, how detailed, how comfortable with change.
- Culture answers whether the way your company operates will bring out their best or wear them down.
McDonald is blunt about the first point: "I've never hired a 100% person in my career, and I've hired lots of people." He says most of his placements had about 70% of the required skills. The rest of the decision came from personality and culture.
Why It Matters: Turnover Is Expensive and Contagious
McDonald cites a study that puts the cost of hiring the wrong person at about one and a half times their on-target earnings. On a $100,000 role, that's roughly $150,000. The money goes to recruiting time or fees, onboarding and training, and the business that doesn't happen while the seat is effectively empty. He gives the example of a salesperson with a $1 million quota who isn't productive for six months at a 40% margin.
The cost doesn't stay on the spreadsheet. McDonald notes that when people who don't fit are let go, "it scares people, quite frankly." Frederick Dudek adds a second layer: the person training a struggling hire loses productivity too, and if that trainer isn't good at teaching, the new hire is set up to fail. One bad match can unsettle an entire team.
Timing raises the stakes. McDonald points to an estimate that 70% of new hires decide within six months whether they'll stay. A company that hires carefully but neglects those first months can still lose the person it worked so hard to find.
Key Lessons for Hiring People Who Stay
1. Define who you're hiring, not just what
Before writing a job description, separate the requirements into three lists. The skills list is the easy one. The personality list describes how the person needs to behave: a hunter who closes new business, a detail-minded account manager, a leader with steady emotional control. The culture list describes the environment they'll walk into, honestly, including the parts that are hard.
2. Stop waiting for the perfect résumé
A candidate with most of the skills and the right personality often outperforms a perfect résumé with the wrong temperament. Skills can be taught. Wiring and fit rarely change. Holding out for a 100% match usually means a longer search and a worse hire.
3. Ask for stories, not opinions
Job descriptions are full of phrases like "good communication skills." McDonald's approach is to qualify those phrases with an anchor, a specific trait such as dealing with ambiguity, and then ask indirect questions: "Tell me about a time." As he puts it, "past behavior is a better predictor of future performance." It doesn't matter whether the story is from yesterday or ten years ago. The details reveal how the person really operates.
4. Look for potential, the way sports teams do
McDonald compares good hiring to recruiting for a sports team. Scouts look at technical skills, such as whether someone can throw the ball. They look at performance skills: how the player handles situations that keep changing. And they look for potential. In a fast-changing business, potential is often the deciding factor, because the role a person is hired for won't be the role they're doing in two years.
He gives an example from Frederick Dudek's own career. As an application engineer, Dudek had learned to overcome objections and solve problems on the spot. Someone saw the similarities to sales, and his tenacity, and moved him into a sales role. The company, McDonald says, "made millions of dollars" from that call.
5. Be honest about what your company can provide
McDonald asks his clients to look inward. If you want to hire a junior person, are you in a position to mentor them? Are you so busy closing business and wearing three hats that a new hire will be left alone? Hiring someone you can't support isn't a hiring decision. It's a retention problem you've scheduled for later.
6. Treat the first six months as part of the hire
McDonald describes a vice president of sales he placed who, weeks after starting, still didn't have a finalized compensation package or clear direction, while the CEO and CFO disagreed. The new executive was losing motivation fast. McDonald's advice was to call the CEO and talk it through. Communication early, he says, is what helps people work through the uncertainty every new job brings.
Dudek adds a common failure: companies that train everything verbally, with no written procedures, then criticize new people for forgetting. People remember only a fraction of what they're told. Written procedures protect both the employee and the business.
7. Listen and value, even when you don't agree
McDonald draws on a family therapist's observation that people feel part of an organization when two things are true: they're listened to, and they're valued. Neither requires agreement. Dudek notes that an employee's perception is their reality, and that a complaint he first disagreed with sometimes turned out to have a real cause worth fixing.
8. Let small gestures carry the weight
Years ago, McDonald kept calling the people of one field service manager, a team of about ten who spent most of each week on planes. He could never get any of them to take a job. When he finally asked the manager for the secret, the answer was small things. The manager gave each new hire $100 to take their spouse to dinner, sent the spouse a dozen roses welcoming them to the company, and accommodated family issues when they came up. When McDonald called his people, they'd tell their manager, and he'd give them an honest opinion, even when that meant saying the job sounded good.
9. Make recognition public
Dudek's view is that people will crawl through broken glass for appreciation and recognition. A private thank-you is good. Stopping a meeting to recognize someone's effort in front of everyone changes how that person feels and how the whole team feels about where they work.
10. Remember that your interview is a preview
McDonald calls the interview process the "here and now." What candidates experience while interviewing is pretty much what they expect to experience as employees. Rescheduled appointments and one-hour interviews cut to thirty minutes send a message. The candidates you most want are often employed, sometimes by competitors, and they talk to others in their industry.
A Practical Framework: Skills, Personality, Culture, and Care
McDonald's three words cover the hiring decision. A fourth step covers everything after it. Use these four questions for every hire.
- Skills: Which abilities are truly required on day one, and which can be learned?
- Personality: Which traits does this role reward? McDonald points to versatility, creativity, and emotional control as the most important in any hire today.
- Culture: Is your company structured and rule-driven, or centered on a founder who changes direction often? Will this person thrive there?
- Care: Who will onboard, mentor, listen to, and recognize this person during their first six months?
For the personality question, McDonald recommends a short trait survey given before the final interview, such as the OAD survey, which graphs assertiveness, extroversion, patience, detail, versatility, creativity, and emotional control. The pattern isn't a verdict. It gives you specific things to explore with the candidate.
Implementation: A 30-Day Hiring Reset
- Week 1: Rewrite the description for the role you hire most often as three lists: skills, personality, and culture. Mark which skills can be taught.
- Week 2: Choose the one or two traits that matter most beyond skills. Write three "Tell me about a time" questions for each.
- Week 3: Write a simple first-90-days plan: who the new hire reports to, who mentors them, when compensation is confirmed, and when you'll check in.
- Week 4: Review your interview experience from the candidate's side. Fix scheduling, set realistic lengths, and decide who answers questions about culture honestly.
Common Mistakes
- Hiring the closest résumé match and skipping personality and fit.
- Asking hypothetical questions ("How would you handle…") instead of asking for real examples.
- Hiring a junior person with no one free to mentor them.
- Leaving compensation or direction unclear for weeks after someone starts.
- Micromanaging. McDonald says a my-way-or-the-highway manager "extinguishes people," and they don't last long.
- Treating employees as a commodity. As Dudek puts it, no employees, no business.
- Running a sloppy interview process and assuming candidates won't notice.
Action Steps
- Pick your next open or likely-to-open role and split its requirements into skills, personality, and culture.
- Write behavioral questions anchored to the most important non-skill trait.
- Name the person responsible for the new hire's first six months before you make an offer.
- Recognize one employee's specific contribution in front of the team this week.
- Choose one small, personal gesture you'll offer every new hire and their family.
Conclusion
Skills get someone through the door. Whether they stay, and whether they tell others it's a great place to work, depends on personality, fit, and how they're treated once they arrive. As McDonald puts it, "the glue that holds people together is feeling valued. And money isn't the only driver."
Build the right environment and the right people find you. Employees talk to friends and former colleagues, partners notice, and candidates start asking how they can work for you. That's what a team of Superfans looks like from the outside.