BUSINESS SUPERFANS® ADVANTAGE • EPISODE 16
Hiring
Revenue Reactor Discipline
Hiring
Blocked Growth Addressed
The primary growth blocker is hiring for skills alone and then failing to make people feel valued, so new hires leave within months, each bad hire costs about one and a half times their earnings, and the team loses momentum.
Primary Stakeholder
Employees
Additional Stakeholders
Job Candidates, Managers and Leadership Team, Employees' Families, Customers, Recruiters and Search Partners
Primary Topic
Hiring for Skills, Personality, and Culture to Attract and Keep Employees Who Become Superfans
DIRECT ANSWER
Companies attract and keep great employees by hiring for more than skills. Michael McDonald looks at three things: skills, personality, and culture fit, and uses behavioral interviews to see how people have really performed. Then, he says, onboard them well, listen to them, and make them feel valued, because that is what keeps people.
Why This Guest’s Perspective Matters
Michael McDonald is the founder and president of M. W. McDonald & Associates (MWM Search), an executive search firm serving high-technology companies since 1991. He has worked in recruiting for 28 years, starting as a CAD/CAM recruiter before running his own firms, and holds a master's degree in counseling psychology. Frederick Dudek says Michael placed him in at least five organizations over the decades.
Key Discoveries From This Conversation
- Root cause: companies hire the résumé, not the person. Michael says he's never hired "a 100% person" in his career; most of his hires had about 70% of the skills, because personality and culture fit make the real difference.
- Misconception: motivation is something you add after hiring. "You hire motivated people, you onboard them, and you don't demotivate them," Michael says. Most people are motivated; the culture decides which direction that goes.
- Strategic shift: hire for potential, the way sports teams do. Teams look at technical skills, performance in changing conditions, and potential. Michael points to an application engineer someone moved into sales for his tenacity. That engineer was Frederick Dudek, and the company "made millions of dollars."
- Practical method: anchor behavioral interviews to one trait. Pick an anchor such as handling ambiguity, then ask "Tell me about a time" questions, because "past behavior is a better predictor of future performance." He adds the OAD survey to map seven work traits before the final interview.
- Business consequence: a bad hire costs about 1.5 times on-target earnings. For a $100,000 hire, Michael puts the loss at about $150,000 in recruiting, onboarding, training, and lost business, plus the fear it spreads when people who don't fit are let go.
- Measurable outcome: small gestures make a team impossible to poach. Michael could never pull any of one manager's 10 field service staff away. The manager gave new hires $100 to take their spouse to dinner and sent the spouse a dozen roses.
- Define who you're hiring, not just what. Write down the skills, then the personality and the culture the person is walking into.
- Hire at 70% of the skills when the rest fits. Skills can be taught; a poor personality or culture fit rarely changes.
- Ask for stories, not opinions. "Tell me about a time" questions show how someone has really handled the trait you need.
- Check what you can give the new hire. If you want a junior hire, make sure someone actually has time to mentor them.
- Treat the first six months as the decision window. Settle pay, direction, and conflicts early, before they push a new hire out.
- Recognize people in front of the team. Public thanks changes how everyone feels, not only the person you thank.
- Run interviews the way you run the company. Candidates read rescheduled or cut-short interviews as a preview of the job.
2:13 — From retail to recruiting — How tenacity and a lot of rejection led to 28 years in recruiting.6:02 — Attracting top talent — Skills, performance, and potential, the way sports teams recruit.8:33 — A business or a glorified job — Why the team has to be able to run the business without the owner.9:32 — Keeping new hires motivated — Hire motivated people, onboard them, and don't demotivate them.11:17 — Skills, personality, culture — Behavioral interviews that show who you're really hiring.14:31 — The cost of a bad hire — About 1.5 times on-target earnings, plus the fear it spreads.16:11 — Building loyalty — Flexibility, recognition, and the $100 dinner that kept a team together.20:56 — Turning employees into Superfans — Listening, valuing opinions, and what people read on Glassdoor.25:29 — Knowing the culture you're joining — Zeus and Apollo cultures from The Gods of Management.29:55 — The interview as a preview — And the OAD survey traits that predict fit.34:35 — How to reach Michael — A free 20-minute hiring consultation.
PUT THIS INTO PRACTICE
Write three "Tell me about a time…" questions for the next role you hire. Pick the one trait that matters most beyond skills, such as handling ambiguity or shifting priorities, and anchor every question to it. Then answer one question yourself: what will your company give this person, and who has time to mentor them? Bring both to your next interview.
If your business can't run without you, you don't own a business. You own a glorified job. The only way out is a team that cares about the company because the company cares about them.
Michael McDonald has spent 28 years on the hiring side of that problem, and his point is simple: skills get someone in the door, but feeling valued is what keeps them. Hire for personality and culture, onboard people properly, and don't leave them waiting weeks to learn their pay or their direction.
I've seen the opposite too many times. No written procedures, everything trained verbally, and then people get chastised when they forget. We only remember about 20% of what we're told. That isn't a people problem. It's a leadership problem.
And never underestimate recognition. People will crawl through broken glass for appreciation and recognition. A private thank-you is good. Recognizing someone in front of the whole team changes how everyone feels. Do it consistently and your employees start telling their friends what a great place it is to work.
What three things does Michael McDonald look for when he helps a company hire?
Michael McDonald sums it up in three words: skills, personality, culture. Skills go in one category, and he says he has never hired "a 100% person"; most of his hires had about 70% of the skills. The difference comes from personality, meaning how a person is wired, and from culture fit, because someone who thrives in one company's culture may not bring the same value to another.
How much does Michael McDonald say a bad hire really costs?
Michael McDonald cites a study that puts the cost of hiring the wrong person at about one and a half times their on-target earnings, so a $100,000 hire costs about $150,000. He adds up recruiting time, onboarding, training, and lost business, such as six unproductive months on a $1 million quota at a 40% margin. He says it also scares the rest of the team.
What is the OAD survey Michael McDonald recommends?
Michael McDonald recommends the OAD survey, which he calls Organizational Analysis Design, given before the final interview. It graphs seven traits: assertiveness, extroversion, patience, detail, versatility, creativity, and emotional control. The pattern shows how a person likes to work, such as a hunter-style salesperson versus a detail-minded specialist. He calls versatility, creativity, and emotional control the most important traits in any hire today.
What are the Zeus and Apollo cultures Michael McDonald describes?
Michael McDonald draws on Charles Handy's The Gods of Management. In a Zeus culture, usually run by an entrepreneur, everything is in the founder's head, direction can change overnight, and you're valued by how Zeus sees you. An Apollo culture is a temple of pillars where success means fitting in and moving up only within your own pillar. He says people who move between the two are often shocked.
- M. W. McDonald & Associates (MWM Search) — Michael McDonald's executive search firm, building teams for high-technology companies since 1991.
- Good to Great by Jim Collins — The book Michael draws on for the idea that every hire sets the path your company will take.
- The Gods of Management by Charles Handy — Michael's recommended read on company culture types, including the Zeus and Apollo cultures.
- OAD (Organizational Analysis Design) survey — The short trait survey Michael recommends giving before the final interview.
- Creating Business Superfans® by Frederick Dudek — Michael quotes its retention chapter on recognition and praise.
- Glassdoor — Where job seekers check what your current and former employees say about you.
No sponsor or approved-partner tools were discussed. Michael McDonald pointed listeners to MWM Search and his free 20-minute hiring consultation, and recommended the OAD survey, Jim Collins's Good to Great, and Charles Handy's The Gods of Management.
Keep Exploring
EPISODE 14
Jannie Teitelbaum's Success Recipe
Customer Experience
Jannie Teitelbaum turned one chicken pot pie into Great Lakes Pot Pies, a Michigan brand sold in 42 grocery stores. She explains how a friendly store, a reward customers reach fast, a happy team, and regular grocery store visits turned customers, employees, and retail partners into Superfans.
Explore Episode 14 →
EPISODE 15
Butch Zemar
Customer Experience
Butch Zemar of Elite Benefits of America has kept some insurance clients for almost 20 years in a business most people treat as a commodity. He explains how small favors, plain-English advice, money-saving plan changes, and free help for referral partners turned clients, staff, and partners into Superfans.
Explore Episode 15 →
EPISODE 13
Steve Feld
Customer Experience
Most service businesses go quiet after the sale, then wonder why referrals and repeat customers dry up. Business coach Steve Feld explains how thank-you cards, employee recognition, easy-to-earn rewards, and fair referral agreements turn customers, staff, and partners into Superfans without more marketing spend.
Explore Episode 13 →
M. W. McDonald & Associates (MWM Search)
Guest Offer
Michael McDonald offers listeners a free 20-minute consultation on hiring, or on anything discussed in this episode. Reach him through his website, mwmsearch.com. If he can't help, he says he can probably point you in the right direction.
Topic Tags
Hiring, Employee Retention, Team Culture, Employee Recognition, Employee Engagement, Trust, Stakeholder Ecosystem