Introduction
Most small businesses work hardest at the start of a relationship. They chase the first sale, interview carefully for the first hire, and push to get a product onto a store shelf. Then the effort drops off. The customer gets a receipt and nothing else. The new employee gets a schedule. The store gets an invoice. A few months later, the owner wonders why repeat business is thin, why good people keep leaving, and why the store quietly stopped reordering.
The relationships didn't fail because the product was bad. They faded because nobody kept them going.
Jannie Teitelbaum, founder and owner of Great Lakes Pot Pies in Clawson, Michigan, built her company the opposite way. A former stockbroker who has always worked in sales, she started making chicken pot pies in her kitchen while semi-retired. Today her pies are carried in 42 grocery stores, with a distributor covering Michigan and much of Ohio. Her approach to customers, employees, and the stores that carry her pies follows one idea: people stay when they feel noticed.
This article draws on Frederick Dudek's conversation with Jannie Teitelbaum on Business Superfans® Advantage, Episode 14: Loyal Customers, Grocery Relationships, Employee Empowerment: Jannie Teitelbaum's Success Recipe.
The Problem: Relationships Treated Like Transactions
The transactional habit shows up in three places at once.
With customers, it looks like a checkout counter where nobody looks up, or a loyalty program so slow to pay out that people forget they joined. With employees, it looks like managers who correct people in front of the whole team and treat every request for time off as an inconvenience. With retail partners, it looks like a supplier who lands the account, ships the first order, and is never heard from again unless they want the store to buy more.
Teitelbaum hears about that last one directly. Store owners and managers have told her that small businesses they buy from disappear once their product is on the shelf. The only contact comes when the supplier wants another order.
Each of these failures is quiet. Nobody complains. People simply drift: the customer tries another brand, the employee takes another job, the store gives the shelf space to someone else.
Why It Matters: Loyalty Compounds Across Every Relationship
The three groups aren't separate. They feed one another.
A happy team creates the experience customers come back for. Visitors to Teitelbaum's store regularly tell her the staff are always smiling and that it looks like a nice place to work. Loyal customers keep the store busy and tell their friends. A store that sees steady sales and regular attention from its supplier keeps reordering, which brings in new customers who have never visited the shop.
The reverse is also true. One unhappy employee can sour a customer's visit, and one neglected store account can quietly remove a product from a whole community.
For a growing business, that compounding effect is the difference between growth that depends on the owner's constant hustle and growth that keeps building on its own.
Key Lessons
Lesson 1: Start with face time
Before Great Lakes Pot Pies was on social media, Teitelbaum built her following at local farmers markets. The work was hard: up at 3:30 in the morning, packing frozen pies into coolers, and setting up a stand every week. But the same customers came back week after week, and they started telling their friends.
"It was really just a face to face time that really built those relationships," she says.
The lesson holds for any business. The first loyal customers usually come from direct, repeated contact, not from advertising. Once those relationships exist, they become the stories, recommendations, and social posts that bring in the next wave.
Lesson 2: Make every visit feel like the neighborhood store
Teitelbaum describes her store as a throwback to the neighborhood shop where everybody knew your name. Every customer gets a greeting when they walk in. The space is colorful and busy. The team works to make people comfortable.
That atmosphere matters even more because her product doesn't require frequent visits. The pies can stay in the freezer for a year and a half, yet many customers come in every week. They come to try something new, so she keeps a wide range of flavors going, including limited items like a taco pie.
Clever names and visible signs help too. Sidewalk signs for "Thanksgiving in a Pie" and the taco pie bring curious passersby through the door to ask what they are.
Even playful moments count. One year, an employee in a turkey suit danced whenever a customer spent more than $100. Teitelbaum says customers deliberately spent enough to see the dance.
Lesson 3: Put the first reward within reach
Loyalty programs often fail because the reward is too far away. Teitelbaum designed hers to pay out fast. Customers enter their phone number at the register, earn 100 points for every $10 they spend, and get $5 off once they reach 1,000 points. Square tracks it all.
"So we've made it so that the customer can get there very quickly," she says.
Frederick Dudek, author of Creating Business Superfans, points out why this matters. When a reward is unattainable, customers decide the program is a gimmick and it backfires. When a customer buys a few items and is already halfway to a reward, the program gives them a reason to come back.
The company's email newsletter works the same way. Teitelbaum's son Steven, who handles marketing and social media, includes a discount or special in nearly every issue.
Lesson 4: Treat the team as the business
Teitelbaum is direct about what her company depends on. "If they're not motivated to do that, I'm going to be out of business because I can't do it myself," she says, listening to her team making pies in the kitchen behind her.
Her approach to keeping them motivated is simple and consistent:
- Reward effort. After the first, very busy week of production for a new distributor, she bought the team lunch and thanked them.
- Celebrate people. Birthdays get lunch, cake, and real attention.
- Say yes to their lives. She never refuses a doctor's appointment or a needed day off; the team works it out in the schedule.
- Trust the work. She hears the team laughing and talking, and she knows the day's goals are getting done.
The result is unusual retention. She says she has lost only two employees: one who retired and one who moved to northern Michigan.
Lesson 5: Correct in private, and mind your delivery
Teitelbaum does correct people when it's needed. What she avoids is doing it in a way that embarrasses them.
"How you say something to somebody, even your children, it's everything," she says. She raises problems politely and always privately.
Dudek describes what happens when managers do the opposite. An employee criticized in front of coworkers feels belittled, dreads coming back to face everyone, and eventually quits. A private, respectful conversation fixes the problem and keeps the person.
Lesson 6: Keep retail partners close
The grocery stores that carry her pies get the same attention as her customers. Teitelbaum or members of her team visit the stores they can reach. The ones that are hours away get phone calls asking what's selling, what isn't, and whether a sign would help. Stores receive small shelf signs that say the pies are Michigan-made and homemade.
The centerpiece is the in-store demo. About every month and a half at nearby stores, an employee sets up a sampling table with signage and an apron. The store places an order before the demo, sells a batch during it, and then has to order again. The team photographs each demo and posts it on social media that day, which sends more shoppers to that store.
The demos do something beyond sales. "It also shows the stores that we're paying attention to them," Teitelbaum says.
Lesson 7: Grow at a pace you can serve
When Great Lakes Pot Pies took on a distributor, Teitelbaum chose one that covers Michigan and much of Ohio instead of one that operates in many more states. A bigger footprint could have put her out of business if she wasn't prepared to supply it.
Growth that outruns production damages the very relationships that create loyalty. Missed deliveries frustrate stores, and an overworked team burns out. Choosing a footprint you can serve well protects both.
Lesson 8: Pair organic reach with targeted ads
Teitelbaum's Facebook page grew to roughly 8,000 followers, she estimates, largely through organic posts about the store, the team, and the demos. She also pays for targeted Facebook ads, and she says they work. Customers come into the store every day saying they kept seeing the company on Facebook and finally had to visit. By her count, half of the store's customers on any given day are new.
The ads bring people in. The relationships, the greeting, and the reward keep them coming back.
A Practical Framework: Notice, Reward, Return
A simple way to apply these lessons is to ask three questions about each group every week: customers, employees, and partners.
- Notice. Who in this group has heard from us recently for a reason other than a sale or a task?
- Reward. Is there a reward, thank-you, or recognition they can actually reach soon?
- Return. What reason have we given them to come back, stay, or reorder?
If the answer for any group is "nobody" or "nothing," that group is where the week's attention belongs.
Implementation: The Next Seven Days
- Day 1: Watch how customers are greeted for one full shift. Fix anything that feels transactional.
- Day 2: Check your loyalty or referral reward. Can a typical customer reach it within two or three visits? If not, lower the threshold.
- Day 3: List every store, partner, or referral source that carries or recommends your work.
- Day 4: Call three of them with no request. Ask what's working and what would help.
- Day 5: Plan one in-person visit, sampling, or demo for a nearby partner.
- Day 6: Do something visible for the team: lunch, a thank-you, or a schedule request you can say yes to.
- Day 7: Post one real photo of your team or a partner event, and put next week's partner calls on the calendar.
Common Mistakes
- Disappearing after the first order. Store managers notice which suppliers keep in touch and which only call to sell.
- Rewards nobody reaches. A distant reward feels like a gimmick and can do more harm than having none.
- Public correction. Embarrassing an employee in front of peers costs far more than the mistake did.
- Treating time-off requests as a nuisance. Flexibility is cheap compared with replacing a good employee.
- Taking on more distribution than you can supply. Missed orders break the relationships you worked to build.
- Relying on ads alone. Ads bring people in once; the experience decides whether they return.
Action Steps
- Greet every customer who walks in or calls.
- Keep your loyalty reward within two or three visits.
- Rotate products or offers so regulars have something new to try.
- Recognize your team often, and accommodate their lives where you can.
- Correct mistakes politely and privately.
- Visit or call your retail and referral partners without asking for an order.
- Run regular demos or events with your partners, and share them online.
- Expand only as fast as you can deliver.
Conclusion
Loyalty is rarely won with a single campaign. It builds from many small moments of attention: a greeting at the door, a reward that arrives soon, a lunch for a tired team, a phone call to a store manager who expected to be forgotten. Teitelbaum grew a pot pie recipe into a regional brand by giving every relationship that kind of attention. As she puts it, the stores can see "that we're paying attention to them." Customers and employees can see it too, and that's what keeps them coming back.